
Veggie treat (Any aubergine + any lettuce): Cows produce plant milk, hens lay green eggs, llamas produce green wool. Spicy Treat (Spicy mushroom + any veggie): Cows produce fire milk, hens produce obsidian eggs (but don't become evil, thankfully), llamas produce red wool. Rainbow Treat (Blue egg + green egg + orange egg): Cows become rainbow cows, produce rainbow milk, hens lay rainbow eggs, llamas produce rainbow wool.
Pumpkin Treat (Any pumpkin + sugar): Cows produce pumpkin spice milk, hens lay orange eggs, llamas produce orange wool.Midnight Treat (Cowberry jam + obsidian egg): Cows produce obsidian milk, chickens become evil, hens lay obsidian eggs, llamas produce black wool.
Healthy Treat (Any fruit/any vegetable + any lettuce): Increases the lifespan of an animal. Golden Treat (Cowberry jam/honey + golden egg): Cows produce golden honey milk, chicken will become a golden chicken, hens will lay golden eggs, llamas produce golden wool. Fruity Treat (Apple jam + blueberry jam): Cows produce enriched milk, hens will lay blue eggs, llamas produce blue wool.
Friendly Treat (Any fruit or veggie): Increases your Sims' relationship with an animal. Flirty Treat (Strawberry jam + sugar): Cows will produce strawberry milk, hens will lay more hatchable, pink eggs, and llamas will produce pink wool. Fishy Protein Treat (Any fish): Each animal will produce +1 extra harvest. Chocolatey Treat (Chocoberry + custard): Cows will produce chocolate milk, hens will lay chocolate eggs, llamas will produce brown wool. Animal Party Treat (Any berry + any mushroom): Fills animal's social need. Here are all the animal treats, their ingredients, and the animal treats' effects in one easy spot for you:
If your Sim has purchased animal treats from the shops in Henford-on-Bagley or won them in some manner, they'll have the recipe for those treats and can make them in the kitchen.